TESTED – New Urban Decay All Nighter Foundation

TESTED – New Urban Decay All Nighter Foundation, Sugar & Spice
174ba urban2bdecay2ball2bnighter

On my recent trip to Johannesburg, I got my hands on the Urban Decay All Nighter Foundation.  I love me some coverage, and I LOVE foundations that stay put, so I figured that this would be a match made in heaven.

TESTED – New Urban Decay All Nighter Foundation, Sugar & Spice
Urban Decay All Nighter liquid foundation.
I really put my all into researching the product before buying it, as I didn’t want to go all the way there, buy the incorrect shade/product, and not be able to swop it.  There were some FABULOUS reviews online, and some not so nice ones.  The things that stood out for me were that this foundation was VERY high coverage, it lasted all day long, BUT it oxidised badly.
For those not in the know – when a foundation makes contact with the air, it can have a chemical reaction and change colour.  I have had this happen a few times to me, and those foundations have ultimately been tossed, or passed on (sometimes it won’t oxidise as badly on another skin).  I mean, who wants to look like an Oompa Loompa after a few hours of wear-time??
With the help of the lovely assistant at the Sandton store, I swatched a few different shades on my neckline, to see how they would oxidise, and then browsed the other products on offer.  I actually took several of these shades, and a couple that wouldn’t suit me, and swatched them on my hands too, just to see how they would oxidise.  They all did, in different time frames – one shade oxidised as I spread it out after pumping the small blob onto my hand!  You really need to know what skin tone you have, and try the shades out with this foundation. Also – the shade looks a lot lighter through the bottle, but once pumped out, it can be a bit darker.

After some debate, we decided that shade 3.0 would work best for me.  It seems quite light when I first apply it, but it only oxidises slightly into a shade that fits my skin better.

TESTED – New Urban Decay All Nighter Foundation, Sugar & Spice
Shade number 3.0
So – let’s skip ahead now (after all the waffling) to the actual review.  I’m going to apologise in advance for constantly comparing this to my Estee Lauder Double Wear foundation, but that is my holy grail product, and I’ve tried so many, so it seems fair that for a foundation to be good for me, it has to somewhat meet those standards.
Urban Decay All Nighter liquid foundation in shade 3.0.  You receive 30ml of product.
TESTED – New Urban Decay All Nighter Foundation, Sugar & Spice
Such gorgeous packaging.
The All Nighter foundation comes in a metallic silver bottle with asymmetrical cutouts.  The packaging looks expensive, edgy and is practical, as you can see the shade of your foundation through the cutouts (although the foundation is slightly darker than it appears through these cutouts).  The foundation is dispensed through an airless pump – very hygienic and you also get every last bit squeezed out, so there is no wastage (something I battle with, with regards to the Estee Lauder Double Wear, as there is always that little bit that I can’t get out).
This is a liquid foundation, but it’s thicker than my Estee Lauder Double Wear foundation, which to me is a true liquid.
TESTED – New Urban Decay All Nighter Foundation, Sugar & Spice
Very, VERY high coverage – I find that one full pump is too much for my face and neck.  I use about half a pump at a time, which means that this should theoretically last for ages.  You need to ensure that you blend the foundation out exceptionally well, or you could look like you’re wearing a mask, as the coverage is so high.
I’ve always found my ELDW (Estee Lauder Double Wear) to be the perfect coverage – you can use a little to just give you a fully covered face that still looks like skin, yet you can build the coverage up depending on the occasion.  I found that I’d have to use the absolute tiniest bit of the Urban Decay in order to give me a still very full-coverage effect.
The formulation of this foundation is oil-free and waterproof.  One would think that this is therefore the ideal foundation for oilier skins, and for summer humidity.
I’ve heard reviews where some people swear by this foundation and others where people found that it caked and crumbled and came off.
Unfortunately, I come somewhere in between these reviews.
On first application, the product is very creamy and easy to apply.  You do have to blend a bit more in order to get it to look completely flawless, but once you’re done it’s beautiful.  It’s matte, it’s poreless, it covers every single little imperfection to the point where I don’t even need concealer.  Basically heaven on earth.
Annndd that’s where things go pear-shaped.
I don’t find that this foundation wears well on me throughout the day.  Granted, I’ve gone off the pill in recent months, and my skin has been a bit oilier than usual, but no matter how I prep my skin beforehand (I’ve tried about 4 different primers, I’ve used every single different moisturiser in my cupboard before using this, from super moisturising, to hydrating, to serious oil-control ones, and I’ve even powdered my skin before applying foundation), this just does not last.  I find that I need to constantly blot my T-zone throughout the day (I don’t have this problem with ELDW or with my L’Oreal Infallible 24h Matte) and the makeup that seamlessly blended into my skin mere hours before now sits in a layer on top of my skin, so that if I bump it with a finger or a phone, it takes that layer off completely.  The end result when I get home at the end of a long day is patchy and greasy.  It also then clings to any teensy bit of dry skin I might have.
I don’t know if I’m doing something incorrectly, applying it poorly or not setting it well (I’ve tried about a dozen different ways in all of these things, and I even set it with my Urban Decay Chill setting spray), but I can’t get this foundation to last the day on me, without blotting and then re-powdering at least twice during the day.
Perhaps it would just work better for normal/combination skin or even drier skins?
There are 24 shades in the range, and we have all 24 available here in South Africa.
R489.95 for 30ml
At the Urban Decay store in Sandton City
Unless I can find a way to make this work better for me, then no, probably not.
Have any of you tried out this foundation?  If so, what did you think?  The mixed reviews make me think that maybe it’s amazing for very specific skins and not so much for others…


Beauty and Lifestyle blogger, wine addict and all-round lover of all things beautiful and sparkly!

This Post Has 7 Comments

  1. Karley

    Awesome, in-depth review. Sorry it was a bit of a disappointment – hopefully you can figure out a way to make it last!

  2. Siobhan Hughes

    Thanks so much! I picked up a tip from a Wayne Goss video on YouTube and going to give it a bash.

  3. R Pillay

    I am quite surprised that the Urban Decay foundation did not work as expected since this product has been raved about by numerous YouTube makeup vloggers. I am still waiting for a store to open in Durban or come up to Jhb( (whichever happens first) so I can try out some Urban Decay products. I hope their other products work out better. Do you recommend anything in particular?
    x Rivania | The Glam Unicorn

  4. Siobhan Hughes

    Hi Rivania!
    I know, I bought it because of all the rave reviews on YouTube and online. I'd debated between the Naked Skin foundation and the All Nighter, and was very disappointed. Granted, my skin has been much oilier of late, so it may just be that. I just don't like buying a product that is meant to be matte and very long lasting, and then having to blot and powder about 3-4 times a day.

    Their eyeshadows are out of this world – I got a single one in Dive Bar and it's so gorgeous and so pigmented. Their Naked Skin concealer is also really good, and is high coverage too!


  5. Marné

    Okay so this is going to sound crazy and I won't blame you for having your doubts over this one:
    Have you tried using a facial oil** as a moisturiser instead of a cream or lotion before applying?
    **I'm talking about a carrier oil like hemp seed oil or safflower oil which are totally non-comedogenic (won't clog pores at all) , with a 5% dilution of essential oils like frankincense, geranium, lavender, tea tree, myrrh, patchouli etc.

    Whenever a foundation don't last on me, I use a self-made skin oil like such above to moisturise before I prime and then apply the foundation. I still set with powder and use a setting spray, and it seems to do the trick. I really hope with all my heart that you find something to make it work, I know how bad it is to be disappointed in (pricey!) product that had great expectations 🙂 xx

  6. Siobhan Hughes

    I've tried it!!!!! It just doesn't work. Perhaps I need to experiment with a few different oils, but I tried two that I had and they really did nothing to help, and in fact made it worse.

    I've seen so many amazing reviews, so maybe it just isn't for me. I'm sad, as it's got such amazing coverage.

    Like I said, I had surgery at the end of August, and I was told that the effects can last up to 12 weeks afterwards. My skin does usually play up after I go under anaesthetic, so I'm hoping that if I continue trying to see if it works, my skin will eventually settle down and it'll come right.

    Thank you so much for your help…


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.